GTS Learn · Dynamics · Intermediate

VCA Compression: Punch and Precision

Also called: voltage-controlled amplifier compressor, console compressor · 6 min read

A VCA compressor uses a voltage-controlled amplifier to turn the signal down, which makes it quick, accurate and easy to aim. It grabs right at the threshold and lets go on schedule, so it is the type engineers reach for when they want punch they can control: drums, bass and anything that needs to hit hard and sit still.

See it work

A simplified model of Drive Strip's compressor, running live in your browser
Compressor
Material
The curve: input level → output level. The shaded band is the knee, where compression eases in.
Top: the material's level and the threshold. Bottom: gain reduction over six seconds, this type against Clean.
Compare with

Leaves out what you hear rather than see: the harmonic color each type adds, and Opto's brighter-listening detector. Audio examples are coming.

What It Echoes

VCA compressors arrived in the 1970s, when engineers could put a precise voltage-controlled amplifier chip in the audio path and drive it from a detector circuit. The result was fast, clean and repeatable, which is why VCA designs ended up in console channel strips, on drum buses and in countless rack units. Most console bus compressors are VCA designs too.

How Drive Strip's VCA Behaves

Drive Strip compressor panel set to VCA: 4:1 ratio, 20 ms attack, 120 ms release, about 3 dB of gain reduction

In Drive Strip, VCA has the tightest knee of the character types, about 2.3 dB, so compression arrives right at the threshold instead of creeping in. Its release runs close to a straight line in dB, which reads as quick and even, and it only stretches slightly after long stretches of compression (about 1.1 times). It adds a little color, mostly odd harmonics in the low end, and only while it is working.

When to Reach for It

  • Snare and kick that need snap: a medium attack lets the hit through, then the body is held in.
  • Bass guitar that needs to sit at one level.
  • Drum bus that needs to hit harder.
  • Anything where you want to set an exact amount of control and know what you’ll get.

Starting Settings

  • Snare: 4:1 ratio, 10 to 30 ms attack, 80 to 150 ms release, 3 to 6 dB of gain reduction.
  • Bass: 4:1 ratio, 5 to 10 ms attack, 120 ms release, 3 to 5 dB.
  • Drum bus: 3:1 ratio, 30 ms attack, 100 ms release, SC HPF at 80 Hz, 2 to 4 dB.

Set the threshold for the gain reduction shown, not by its number: the right threshold depends on how loud the track is.

Common Mistakes

  • A fast attack on drums. Below about 5 ms, VCA clamps the transient and the drum goes flat. Back the attack off until the hit returns.
  • A release that never recovers. On a busy part, if the meter never returns to zero between hits, the release is too slow for the tempo.
Go deeper: how it works inside Advanced · equations

The gain computer: threshold, ratio and knee

Every Drive Strip type starts from the same static curve. With x the level above the threshold in dB, R the ratio and W the knee width, the gain reduction is:

below the knee  (2x < −W):   0
inside the knee (2|x| ≤ W):   (1/R − 1) · (x + W/2)² / (2W)
above the knee  (2x > W):    (1/R − 1) · x

Inside the knee the reduction grows as a square, so the ratio slides smoothly from 1:1 up to the full ratio across W dB. That is the curve in the demo's left plot; the shaded band is W.

The detector and the ballistics

The detector holds each peak for a moment (20 ms, or 8.3 ms on FET) so a steady tone reads as its true peak. The gain is then smoothed in dB: attack is a one-pole toward more reduction, and release moves back toward the curve at a rate that depends on how far it still has to go:

dg/dt = k · d^p        d = distance left to recover, in dB

With p = 1 that is a plain exponential. Below 1 the release runs closer to a straight line in dB; above 1 it starts fast and slows down as it nears the end, the long two-stage tail of optical and FET compressors. k is set so that 63 % of the recovery lands on the Release knob for every type, which is why the knob means the same thing everywhere.

Where the color comes from

A compressor that follows the waveform inside each cycle wobbles the gain at the signal's own frequency. That wobble is distortion: mostly the 3rd harmonic, strongest on low notes, falling about 6 dB per octave. Each character type adds a fitted amount of it back on purpose, plus a small fitted amount of 2nd harmonic. Both scale with how hard the compressor is working, so at 0 dB of gain reduction every type is clean.

VCA in those terms

VCA's release exponent is a little below 1, so the release runs closer to a straight line in dB than a plain exponential (a shape index of 1.84). Its knee is 2.3 dB, the hardest of the six, and a small release memory stretches the release about 1.1 times after sustained compression. Its color is mostly the detector ripple, so it is odd-led and strongest on low notes.

From the GTS Lab

Measured from Drive Strip’s own compressor, all six types side by side. VCA is in bold.

TypeKneeRelease shapeRelease memoryDetectorColor
Clean6 dB2.2 · plain exponential1.0 · noneflatnone
VCA2.3 dB1.84 · near-straight in dB1.12flatlight, odd-led
FET6.7 dB5.05 · strong two-stage2.14flatmost: odd and even
Opto6.25 dB3.94 · two-stage1.02+5.7 dB at 4 kHzlight, odd-led
Vari-Mu12.2 dB1.88 · smooth1.00 · noneflatgentle, even-led
Bus8.4 dB3.01 · two-stage15.7 · auto releaseflatlight, odd only

Release shape is (t90 − t10) / t63, the time from 10 % to 90 % of the recovery divided by the time to 63 %: about 1.3 is a straight line in dB, 2.2 a plain exponential, above 3 a fast-then-slow two-stage release. Release memory is how much slower the release is after 3 seconds of compression than after a short burst; 1.0 means no change. Detector is how much more the compressor hears 4 kHz than 1 kHz.

Keep Going

New to compression? Start with Compression basics, six short steps from what a compressor does to parallel compression.

The other five types

Read more

  • Compressor types compared: all six side by side, and how to choose
  • Six Compressors in One Strip: the deep dive, with quick picks for every source
  • Giannoulis, Massberg and Reiss, “Digital Dynamic Range Compressor Design: A Tutorial and Analysis”, Journal of the Audio Engineering Society 60(6), 2012: the standard reference for how digital compressors are built
  • Dynamic range compression: the basics, on Wikipedia

Hear all six on your own tracks. Drive Strip comes with a perpetual license for three machines: no iLok, no subscription, and a free 14-day trial of the whole plugin.

1176, LA-2A, Fairchild and SSL are trademarks of their respective owners. They are named only to describe a style of compressor; Golden Turtle Sound is not affiliated with them, and Drive Strip’s compressor types are not models of their products.